Carb Attack: Mac ‘n’ Cheese Grilled Cheese

As some of you may know, our very own gansie has been on a mission to find the best grilled cheese in DC. One place she hasn’t yet ventured is my kitchen. What you see above is a mac ‘n’ cheese grilled cheese. Only you ESers would appreciate something as beautiful as this and wouldn’t mind that it means you have to hit the gym or an extra hour or two (or in my case actually going for once).

For those of you who remember Grilled Cheese Truck’s entry in America’s top 10 new sandwiches, this is like that one, only fancied up. I’m sure any old mac ‘n’ cheese recipe would work well, even, dare I say it — Kraft — but I went with a truffle mac ‘n’ cheese that I adapted from this recipe.

16oz pasta (your choice of shape)
8oz grated fontina
8oz grated parmesan
1 T fresh black truffle shavings (if available)
2 T fresh thyme, chopped
1 whole head of garlic, roasted.
1 cup of cream
1/2 cup brandy
Bread crumbs

Heat the oven to 350 degrees, roast the garlic in foil for about 30-45 minutes.

Boil water for pasta and cook until al dente.

Heat a a little of the olive oil in a pan, toss in the garlic and half of the truffle shavings (if you don’t have fresh truffle you can always substitute half of the EVOO with truffle oil), thyme and a pinch of s&p. Heat for 5 minutes. Add in the brandy and reduce to about half. Pour in the cream and simmer. Stir in the grated fontina until melted.

Stir in the cooked pasta until all the pasta is covered in the cheese mixture, pour in the grated parmesan and stir until fully mixed. Pour into oven proof dish or cast iron pan (I used my Le Creuset), sprinkle over the remaining shaved truffle and enough bread crumbs to coat.

Bake in the oven for about 15 minutes or until golden brown.

For the actual grilled sandwich part I used a fresh wheat grain bread (I went the healthier route), thickly sliced. Melt a little butter in the microwave and brush one side of each slice. Heat a grill pan to medium-high and place a slice of bread butter side down, “spread” over a layer of the mac n cheese and place the other slice of bread butter side up. Cover with the panini press and grill for two minutes, turn over and grill for another two minutes or until each side is charred.

A couple of tips: I always heat the panini press by leaving it on the grill pan for a few minutes. Also, if you don’t have a panini press you can always use the bottom of a heavy pot to press the sandwich or if you have a George Forman, then even better.

Serve with a glass of fat-free milk.


You may also like


  • Alessandra March 29, 2011  

    Wow, I opened this email up and literally smelled the mac n cheese. Only 2 hours till lunch, only 2 hours till lunch….

  • Cary March 29, 2011  


  • erica March 29, 2011  

    haha, cary.

  • JoeHoya March 30, 2011  

    Is it bad that this made me think of CiCi’s macaroni & cheese pizza?

    I think it might be.

  • Emily March 30, 2011  

    Dang, I was thinking of making my own fancified grilled mac & cheese after discovering that one in America’s top 10 new sandwiches as well. One time in LA I got a mac & cheese topped hot dog. I look back fondly on that day.

    I think I feel the same way about mac & cheese as I do about coleslaw: top/fill any kind of sandwich-y thing with it and it will be good.

  • Kathy - Panini Happy March 31, 2011  

    I just made a pilgrimage up to the Grilled Cheese Truck last week to try this sandwich! I tried the version with the ribs and caramelized onions – I guiltily enjoyed every bite. 🙂

  • order Takeaways Online August 10, 2011  

    Wow ! Yummy Carb Attack . Cheesy .

  • SA December 10, 2011  

    Add thinly sliced tomato and some perfectly cooked bacon — or even better, Canadian bacon!


  • Diane April 12, 2013  

    My ultimate mac & cheese grilled cheese sandwich included a layer of pulled pork underneath it and more oozy sharp cheddar atop the mac and cheese…Mmmmm! Yes, the skim milk is a must have!! :))

Leave a comment