Top 10 Creepy Halloween Recipes
Is it just us, or do Halloween recipes get creepier and simultaneously more delicious every year? Here are our top 10 favorite finds from around the web:
10. Bloody Eyeballs

Canary Girl shaped her olive-topped eyes out of ground chicken, but suggests you can also use ground pork (or ground whatever you like).
9. Witches’ Fingers

Las Vegas Food Adventures is baking these bloody (and yummy) almond-topped cookies.
8. Chicken Potpie with Crawling Hands

Woman’s Day deconstructs potpie, with some added body parts.
7. Mummy Dogs

My Little Corner of Savings has a recipe for these crescent roll and hot dog creations. The little mustard eyes are a nice touch.
6. Morning Mummys

Meat-free fiends can still get in on the mummy action by going with unfurled’s nutella-and-frosting wrapped bodies
5. Mummy Meatloaf

Sticking with the corpse theme, Family Corner is cooking up this Lasagna-wrapped meatloaf.
4. Bloody Worms

Classics don’t get old, and who doesn’t like eating worms” The Idea Room has this spin, made from straws (they’re edible in the end).
3. Shrunken Heads in Cider
![]()

Count on that freak Martha Stewart to turn granny smith apples into this creepy bowl of heads.
2. Jello Brain

Amazon has your brain mold (if by chance you don’t already have one in your kitchen), and thirteen for halloween has the recipe to make it even grosser.
1. Eyeball Caprese

Of the many, many eyeball recipes out there, Evil Mad Scientist finds the perfect balance between gross-out and appetizing with this eyeball caprese salad.
More Halloween Coverage on Endless Simmer:
Top 10 Sexiest Food Halloween Costumes
Top 10 Weirdest Food Halloween Costumes
Top 10 Cutest Food Halloween Costumes




I thought, at first glance, the Mummy Dogs were Taliban Dogs…is that bad?
I thought, at first glance, the Mummy Dogs were Taliban Dogs…is that wierd?
OMG, I love all those mummys! Who knew there were so many mummy themed snacks out there?
Thank you so much for including me in your Top 10, I feel so honored.
Love the recipes! These will be great for any halloween party or even just for the family!